Make a Payment/ Report a Claim

Adirondack Insurance Exchange

Report A Claim: 877-629-8003

Allegany Cooperative Insurance Co.

Report A Claim: 877-346-0300

American Modern Insurance Co.

Report A Claim: 800-375-2075

AmTrust Group

Report A Claim: 888-239-3909

Eastern Mutual Insurance Company

Report A Claim: 877-302-0203

Foremost Insurance Group

Report A Claim:
Auto Claims: 800-274-7865
All Other Claims: 800-527-3907

Guard Insurance Companies

Report A Claim: 888-639-2567

Hagerty

Report A Claim: 800-922-4050, ext. 4

Kemper Preferred

Report A Claim: 888-252-2799

Liberty Mutual

Report A Claim: 844-825-2467

Main Street America Group

Report A Claim: 877-425-2467

Merchants Insurance Group

Report A Claim:
NJ & East PA: 800-322-8608
NY & West PA: 800-952-5246

Mercury Insurance Group

Report A Claim: 800-503-3724

Mid-Hudson Cooperative Insurance Co.

Report A Claim: 800-721-5001

National General Insurance Group

Report A Claim: 800-325-1088

Nationwide Insurance

Report A Claim: 800-421-3535

New Jersey Skylands

Report A Claim: 888-855-4622

Preferred Mutual Insurance

Report A Claim: 800-333-7642

Progressive Insurance Co.

Report A Claim: 800-274-4499

Safeco Insurance Co.

Report A Claim: 800-332-3226

Travelers Insurance Co.

Report A Claim:
Personal Lines: 800-252-4633
Commercial Lines: 800-238-6225

Universal Property & Casualty

Report A Claim: 800-470-0599

Utica First Insurance Co.

Report A Claim: 800-456-4556